CAPRISA Faces Labour Court Challenge Over R73,000 Salary Deduction
The Centre for the AIDS Programme of Research in South Africa (CAPRISA) is facing a Labour Court challenge over its decision to deduct R73,245.21 from the final remuneration of its former head of communications, Sinenhlanhla Jimoh, in a dispute over relocation expenses.
The matter is scheduled to be heard at the Durban Labour Court on Thursday, 15 October 2026, almost two years after Jimoh resigned from the Durban-based research institution.
The dispute stems from relocation expenses incurred when Jimoh left her permanent position at the National Institute for Communicable Diseases (NICD) in Johannesburg to join CAPRISA in January 2024.
CAPRISA maintains that the relocation expenses are recoverable following her resignation. However, Jimoh’s case challenges the enforceability of the repayment conditions and the institution’s decision to deduct the disputed amount from her final remuneration.
ALSO READ: High Court dismisses Mogalakwena Municipal Manager’s urgent application
At the centre of the dispute are questions about when CAPRISA disclosed its relocation policy, whether the repayment conditions formed part of Jimoh’s employment agreement, and whether the institution was legally entitled to withhold the money.
Jimoh joined CAPRISA after more than seven years at the NICD, where she served as a senior communications manager. Her appointment required her to relocate from Johannesburg to Durban.
According to the account underpinning the legal proceedings, CAPRISA provided extracts of its relocation policy during the recruitment process in October 2023. The dispute concerns whether these extracts adequately disclosed the conditions under which she would be required to repay the relocation expenses if she left the organisation within a specified period.
In May 2024, approximately four months after she joined CAPRISA, Jimoh was presented with an acknowledgement of debt relating to the relocation costs.
Correspondence from that period indicates that questions were raised about the proposed agreement. Her case maintains that the concerns were not adequately addressed and that she did not sign the acknowledgement of debt.
ALSO READ: The Greenery in Polokwane rated best shopping centre in SA
The timing of the disclosure of the full relocation policy is another key issue. Jimoh’s case places the disclosure after she had already submitted her resignation, by which time she had left her previous employment, relocated to Durban and worked at CAPRISA for several months.
Jimoh resigned in October 2024 and left the institution the following month. CAPRISA subsequently withheld R73,245.21 from her final remuneration, citing its relocation arrangements.
The Labour Court will be asked to determine whether the repayment conditions formed part of the parties’ employment agreement, whether those conditions were enforceable and whether CAPRISA was entitled to recover the disputed amount through a deduction from her final remuneration.
Section 34 of the Basic Conditions of Employment Act regulates deductions from employees’ remuneration and restricts the circumstances in which employers may make them. These include certain deductions authorised by law or agreed to in writing by an employee in respect of a debt.
The proceedings are therefore expected to examine both the basis of CAPRISA’s alleged claim for repayment and whether the deduction complied with the applicable legal requirements.
The employment agreement, relocation policy, unsigned acknowledgement of debt and correspondence between the parties are expected to be central to the dispute. The court has yet to make a finding on the merits of the case.
ALSO READ: Queen Masalanabo appointed Deputy Chair of SA’s Majesties
The dispute also involves allegations concerning discussions between Jimoh and CAPRISA’s senior management about the repayment of the relocation expenses.
According to the account of those discussions, references were allegedly made to the institution’s financial resources and its ability to pursue litigation. The remarks were reportedly understood as a warning about the potential consequences of challenging CAPRISA’s position.
However, the circumstances and meaning of the alleged remarks remain disputed, and no finding of intimidation has been made.
CAPRISA is a prominent South African research institution known for its work in HIV prevention, tuberculosis and infectious diseases. The organisation collaborates with research institutions and international funders on clinical research and public health programmes.
The legal challenge centres on the terms under which Jimoh was recruited and the institution’s subsequent efforts to recover relocation expenses. While relocation assistance is commonly offered to professionals recruited from other cities, repayment arrangements may apply when employees leave within an agreed period.
In this case, the parties disagree over whether the relevant conditions were properly disclosed and incorporated into their agreement, as well as whether the deduction from Jimoh’s final remuneration was lawful.
When approached for comment, Jimoh declined to discuss the matter, citing the fact that it is sub judice.
CAPRISA’s communications manager, Minoshni Pillay, also declined to comment, citing the same reason.
“Please note that the matter in question is currently sub judice and as such we will not be issuing any comment at this time. We will be guided by the court process and will communicate further when it is appropriate to do so,” Pillay said.
The case is registered under number D13/2025 and is scheduled to be heard at the Durban Labour Court on 15 October 2026.
